The well-known Pasapalabra case involved a dispute between Atresmedia, ITV and MC&F over the intellectual property rights to “El Rosco”, the final round of the television game show. The dispute raised a particularly significant question in intellectual property law: when does a television format cease to be a mere idea and become a work eligible for copyright protection? It also concerned the degree of originality required for such protection to arise.
The case also presented a particular procedural challenge due to previous litigation concerning Pasapalabra, before the courts in Madrid, in which ITV's rights to the programme format had been recognised and “El Rosco” had been regarded as one of its essential elements. The subsequent proceedings, brought in Barcelona, once again raised closely related questions concerning the nature and ownership of those rights. This placed at the heart of the dispute the limits of res judicata and the extent to which an earlier final judgment could have binding effects in subsequent proceedings involving different parties.
BGA advised and assisted in Atresmedia's defence in these proceedings, with Blas González acting as co-counsel alongside Baylos and CMS.
The dispute ultimately reached the Spanish Supreme Court, which, in its Judgment No. 2182/2026 of 19 May, having ruled out the application of res judicata arising from the earlier Madrid proceedings, held that “El Rosco”, by virtue of its level of development, structure and complexity, constituted a television format capable of independent copyright protection, and recognised MC&F as the owner of the intellectual property rights to that format.
The principal legal issues examined in the case include:
- A boundary case concerning the scope and binding effect of res judicata, involving two closely related sets of proceedings concerning the same subject matter before the courts in Madrid and Barcelona.
- The concepts of objective and subjective originality.
- Television formats as copyright-protected works.
